- Print Magazine
- Digital Magazine
- Newsletter
Cover Story
After two years of record inflation, consumers expected (perhaps naively) that prices would eventually return to normal. When that didn’t happen in 2024, “We saw a new, likely long-term consumer mindset solidify,” say the authors of dunnhumby’s eighth annual Retailer Preference Index, published earlier this year. With high prices here to stay for at least the foreseeable future, they explain, “Th e importance of delivering savings is more important than it has ever been. At the same time, the importance of delivering quality, while second overall in our model, is less important than it has ever been.” And that was before any talk of tariffs.
Consumers’ laser-focus on savings is one of the reasons we chose Batavia, Ill.-based deep discounter Aldi, which ranked fifth overall and No. 1 in everyday low prices in dunnhumby’s study, as our 2025 Retailer of the Year.
Just how good are Aldi’s prices? Its shoppers can save up to 36% on an average shopping trip (22% if they typically buy competitors’ private labels), which translates into annual savings of nearly $3,900 for a family of four, according to the chain’s own Price Leadership Report, released earlier this year. But low prices aren’t Aldi’s only claim to fame. It also rates surprisingly well on quality — the other half of the value equation.
“Aldi’s biggest strength is its price leadership. It’s a key point of difference in the market and part of its promise to consumers. It’s what Aldi is known for,” says Neil Saunders, managing director of retail at New York-based GlobalData. “However, Aldi deepens this by delivering value. It’s not just one of the cheapest retailers; it also tries to provide great products and a pleasant shopping experience,” differentiating the chain from dollar stores and other deep discounters that require a tradeoff between low prices and quality. Indeed, 40.9% of consumers who shop Aldi most often for frozen foods say they go there because of the quality, significantly higher than regular shoppers at the average U.S. supermarket (33.2%) and Walmart (28.8%), according to results of a Prosper Insights & Analytics’ consumer survey (see chart on page 30).

Noticeable improvements in store design have made the shopping experience more pleasant — without undermining the value proposition.
The real proof is in the parking lot, where Acuras and Range Rovers often sit next to Kias and Hyundais, says Gary Stibel, founder and CEO of Westport, Conn.-based New England Consulting Group. “Clearly, Aldi isn’t just catering to the poor or economically stressed,” he says. In fact, London-based Kantar reports that 38% of Aldi’s U.S. shopper base earns more than $100,000 per year.
That finding is reinforced by the team at Cadent Consulting Group, Evanston, Ill., who say that from 2023 to 2024, Aldi’s growth among upper-income households was faster than any other grocery retailer’s. “Saving is critical to consumers right now, especially in the grocery space where pricing is visible and shoppers can assess changes on every trip,” says managing partner and CEO Richard Bode. “It’s the No. 1 area where shoppers — at every income level — are experiencing price pressure.” Not surprisingly, he continues, 50% of low-income households say they plan to shop more at dollar and discount retailers in the year to come. But what may come as a surprise is the fact that 35% of high-income households plan to do the same.
Evidence of another interesting shift comes from Covina, Calif.-based Placer.ai, which reports a slight drop in the percentage of Aldi shoppers who come directly from or go directly to another grocer, “solidifying the chain’s position as a go-to destination for full grocery hauls.” The company also reported an 18.2% increase in store traffic from 2023 to 2024, which has continued through every week of 2025. Although Placer.ai attributed some of that growth to store expansion, it also tallied a 13.5% increase in visits per location.

Value messaging highlighting the chain’s low price leadership is prominently displayed in stores.
While Aldi added approximately 400 Winn-Dixie and Harvey’s locations in the Southeast to its portfolio last year following a blockbuster deal with Southeastern Grocers, it recently offloaded 170 of them. “They saw an opportunity to acquire a lot of stores and customers — and they went for it,” says Saunders. “It had to buy the company as a package to get the stores it wanted, and then it sold off the locations where it doesn’t see potential.”
But even with the sell-off, Aldi is on track to open a record 225+ new stores this year, including approximately 100 of the former Winn-Dixie and Harvey’s locations that it hung onto. The remainder will be converted by the end of 2027, according to the company. In addition to its strong push into Florida and other Southeastern states, Aldi continues to expand westward. Its first two Las Vegas stores opened last month, with a third expected to debut May 15 and another later this year. Stores in Arizona and Southern California are also in the works this year.

Aldi has added refrigerated space for single-serve products popular among younger consumers in particular.
How is Aldi faring in these new markets? Though competitive dynamics vary considerably from market to market, “In general, Aldi competes very well with incumbents and usually takes share from the middle market because it’s far more price-focused,” says GlobalData’s Saunders. It may have a tougher time in, say, New Hampshire where equally price-focused Market Basket (our 2022 Retailer of the Year) maintains a fiercely loyal customer base, he adds. But the chain isn’t shying away from clashes with Walmart, placing several of its new stores within shouting distance of the industry behemoth.
Aldi has made noticeable improvements in store design, making them easier and more pleasant to shop. Because many of the stores are new, “They actually feel more upscale than a lot of the older stores operated by Kroger and other traditional retailers,” says Saunders. But Aldi execs have been careful not to go too far.
“Aldi’s value proposition is tied directly to the store itself,” explains Simon Johnstone, senior director retail insights at London-based Kantar. “If stores look more premium or expensive, lower-income shoppers especially may start to doubt the value or the deals they’re getting there. We saw this play out in Germany — where the [deep discounter] model was first founded — when Aldi and Lidl had to scale back store refurbishment plans.”
Stibel, too, likes that Aldi stores are a little more utilitarian than mainstream competitors. “That’s a good thing because people understand that [extra features] cost money,” which they would rather be put toward lower prices.
“So keep making customers bag their own groceries, keep making them return their own carts and keep merchandising products in display shippers — because it all speaks to value,” he says.
To further drive home that point, Aldi appears to be doubling down on value messaging in-store, says Johnstone, noting the ubiquity of signage highlighting the chain’s low-price leadership. He adds, “Aldi’s strength has always come from its ability to build awareness of its differences versus traditional supermarkets and, over time, its real strength is that it’s better at defining its advantages over other formats.

Representing approximately 20% of sales, Aldi Finds help create the treasure hunt experience shoppers love. But out-of-stocks can be frustrating.
While price and quality are the hallmarks of Aldi’s offer, the chain also gets high marks for its distinctive assortment. In fact, more than twice as many respondents to Prosper’s most recent poll say they choose Aldi for its “unique and exciting products” than those who choose Walmart for the same reason, differentiating the retailer even further.
Although Aldi only carries about 2,000 products at any given time (versus 30,000 at a typical grocery store), the selection is well-curated, with between 5% and 10% of SKUs described as “regional” favorites. Many of those items are “Aldi Finds,” i.e. seasonal and other items only available for a limited time and in limited quantities.
“Aldi Finds have developed a cult following among shoppers who mark their calendars for the Wednesday announcement [of each week’s deals] and quickly flock to stores,” says Drew Fischer, senior business manager at Cadent Consulting Group. “This section accounts for approximately 20% of sales and is designed to surprise and delight customers with new offers, providing an enticing ‘treasure hunt’ atmosphere” that keeps them coming back for more, he adds.
The only drawback is the possibility that shoppers will be disappointed when a new item they love is no longer available, which is a common complaint. Still, Saunders believes that as long as the core offer — the basics — remains in stock, the strategy is a good way to create excitement and drive traffic, especially since stores that average only about 18,000 square feet can’t possibly carry everything consumers want all the time.

Despite its limited assortment, Aldi gets high marks for offering unique and exciting products.
That said, Aldi’s limited assortment, especially the lack of national brands, presents a problem for a certain percentage of the population that will probably never shop there, limiting the potential for growth somewhat. “Americans are used to having a vast number of choices and some struggle with the more limited range,” explains Saunders. “However, even here, sentiment has shifted a bit, and more consumers appreciate the smaller ranges that allow them to shop more efficiently.”
Of course, the vast majority — upwards of 90% — of Aldi’s offer is private label. While that may have once been viewed as a major drawback, times have changed, says Fischer, citing the continued growth and increasing sophistication of store brands. He notes that 53% of U.S. consumers say they expect to buy more private label in 2025, which bodes well for retailers such as Aldi with comprehensive programs that go well beyond the basics.
For example, says Fischer, while there’s Season’s Choice frozen fruits and veggies, Priano frozen pasta, Mama Cozzi’s pizza, Sundae Shoppe ice cream and frozen novelties, and Fremont Fish Market frozen seafood, there’s also liveGfree gluten-free foods, Simply Nature organic products and Specially Selected gourmet fare. The fact that each category has its own unique store brand “offers an experience similar to shopping at a traditional grocery store,” he adds.
While Aldi offers a strong selection of both frozen and refrigerated products, including a lot of meal solutions, the chain has added more refrigerated space for new single-serve items in particular (think snack packs, salads, sandwiches, heatand-eat soups and other meals, protein bars and healthy beverages). “Refrigerated is a big area of focus in new stores, with a prominent back wall position,” reports Saunders, who says the move corresponds with refrigerated growth across channels.
The increased emphasis on single-serve refrigerated items is also expected to help boost Aldi’s appeal among younger consumers since, according to Prosper’s latest survey, the chain’s customer base skews a bit older than the average supermarket’s — and Walmart’s. “To attract that new, younger shopper, not only now but in the next five to 10 years, retailers are asking what they’re looking for. And it’s those single-serve products that are making their lives easier by allowing them to recreate restaurant experiences at home,” says Cadent Consulting’s Bode.
In conjunction with its increasing focus on the refrigerated department, Aldi is leading the way in refrigeration sustainability, a role it doesn’t often get enough credit for. But it was the first U.S. retailer to commit to transitioning to natural refrigerants in all stores (by 2035), a move that has already lowered potential carbon emissions by over 50% (since 2015). In addition, reports Fischer, “Aldi has the most GreenChill-certified stores of any retail food company.” While the chain’s German parent company is probably more eco-conscious than many U.S.-based retailers, “It’s probably more about saving money in the long run,” he says. Despite the upfront investment, “I’m sure there’s a payoff in the end.”
Aldi is also taking a leadership role in the technology arena. With its ALDIgo launch, for example, it was the first major U.S. retailer to implement checkout-free technology, eliminating a pain point for many shoppers and giving the chain a way to further reduce labor costs. Though only available at a handful of Midwest locations, ALDIgo speaks to the retailer’s willingness to invest in technologies that support its core values.
One area that it hasn’t yet jumped into is online shopping, which is only available through a partnership with Instacart. Within that framework, however, the chain is rolling out some new technologies intended to improve the omnichannel shopping experience. For example, carrot tags installed at more than 100 Aldi locations in Ohio and Illinois allow consumers to select an item on their phone and trigger a flashing electronic tag in-store so it’s easy to find.
“Aldi knows its shopper, and it’s done its homework,” says Cadent Consulting’s Bode. “So it’s investing in ways to make the treasure hunt a really great experience” because that’s what’s important to its customers.
In another departure from many mainstream supermarkets, Aldi doesn’t offer a loyalty card, which Saunders doesn’t view as a drawback. “Aldi generates loyalty through its prices and its value proposition,” he explains. “Part of its business model is simplicity and not burdening the business with functions that aren’t core to the mission as that’s what keeps costs low.” He adds, “I’m sure the data would be interesting, but Aldi seems to have a pretty clear understanding of its customers already.”
But Johnstone isn’t so sure. “Aldi’s biggest competitor [in Europe], Lidl, has leveraged its loyalty card to drive significant levels of growth and loyalty,” he reports. “And if you look at other limited assortment grocers, especially in Europe, most of them have plans to add a loyalty program or are already offering one. So I suspect Aldi will be doing it or trialing it in some markets over the coming years. Whether Aldi USA follows suit, it’s too soon to tell,” adds Johnstone. But if Lidl continues to grow its presence in the states, the odds may go up.

A refrigerated meal solutions set near the store entrance allows shoppers in a hurry to grab dinner and go
Tough but fair is the consensus among manufacturers we talked to. In order to get the lowest possible price, “They’ll squeeze you for every last nickel,” says one long-time supplier, citing Aldi’s famously tight margins. But the reward is huge volume.
For example, says one vendor, its branded product typically retails for $9.49, but as an Aldi Find, it goes for $7.99, “made possible by the chain’s large volume ordering and streamlined operations, without the typical deductions other retailers require.” (Suppliers work with the chain directly, so there are no broker fees or marketing costs.)
“Aldi’s operational efficiency is unmatched,” confirms another manufacturer. “From streamlined SKU selection to rapid product turnover, they’ve mastered a lean, focused approach that many retailers aspire to but rarely execute this well.”
Vendor partners also applaud Aldi’s commitment to sustainability, not only in regards to raw materials but also packaging. “It forces you to become a better company yourself,” says one. That said, not every manufacturer is ready for that — or prepared to offer the unique package sizes or case counts that Aldi may require. And, of course, the movement requirements are substantial. So it’s not always a good fit.
While one long-time private label supplier says Aldi is a good partner that offers accurate forecasts and helps develop new ideas to drive volume, another claims the chain’s highly centralized decision-making process sometimes creates friction, “especially for suppliers bringing differentiated products or emerging trends.” As such, he continues, “Flexibility and more openness to collaboration could go a long way toward further strengthening those relationships.”
The other knock on Aldi comes from suppliers who are also customers. “They do a nice job building creative assortments so consumers have a chance to experiment with new products at a reasonable price,” explains one vendor. “The downside is that if you like it, you may never see it again.” He adds, “Aldi also needs to do a better job keeping the cases full. No matter what city I’m in, they seem to struggle with on-shelf [availability].”
Another manufacturer thinks the chain would benefit from rotating in more regional or specialty brands that reflect local shopper preferences. “The chain mentioned to us that having familiar brands helps them attract customers, which is a smart strategy. So I think they should lean into that more,” she says. Yes, private brands are Aldi’s bread and butter, but offering some local favorites at a screaming hot price only enhances the value proposition.
Despite their constructive criticism, do vendors think Aldi is worthy of Retailer of the Year honors? Absolutely. “In a market where many retailers chase trends, Aldi has stuck to its formula. And it works,” says one.
“The chain’s ability to keep prices low without compromising product standards is unmatched,” adds another. “And its model of simplicity and efficiency sets a strong example in today’s cost-conscious market.”
Given the current economy, “Saving money is vital to the average American right now,” says Saunders. “Food inflation has been hefty over the past few years and despite some moderation in recent months…many shoppers still suffer from register shock when they see their total, which has driven them right into the arms of Aldi.”
Based on evidence from previous economic downturns, many of those new Aldi shoppers are likely to stay with the chain even after the economy improves. Add that to significant opportunities for continued expansion, and the sky’s the limit.
“I think Aldi is particularly well-positioned to gain share right now,” confirms New England Consulting Group’s Stibel, who uses an analogy from the racing world to support his position. “Smart race car drivers love the rain because it’s easier to pass when others are slowing down,” he says. So while Kroger and Albertsons are regrouping after their failed merger and other retailers are waiting out the tariffs or hunkering down for a recession, “Aldi is quickly moving ahead.”
As long as the chain stays in its lane, it’s likely to come away the winner.